Does Instructional Design Outdo Visual Design?

Just a few years back a movie titled - 'The Inception'. The plot line of which was as complex as any Christopher Nolan movie and got a mixed review across the globe. While some found the movie interesting due to the intriguing story, some liked it purely due to the visual aspects. What made it successful was the delicate balance between the narrative and visuals. What would have happened if either of those had overpowered the other? The movie would then only be accepted by a selective few.

Something similar works in the case of effective eLearning too. The content-its narrative-and the images or media elements used all play a part in delivering learning effectively. Simply put, there are two parts to eLearning: Instructional Design and Visual Design. But, which one has the upper hand when it comes to the final eLearning course. While it is often arbitrated that, a strong, well devised Instructional design model is the key to creating an extraordinary course, it doesn’t always have to be so.

To understand better we have to dig a bit deeper. To get started, the term Instructional Design is defined by IDC as, "the systematic process by which instructional materials are designed, developed, and delivered." Visual Design on the other hand is defined as, "the use of imagery, color, shapes, typography, and form to enhance usability and improve the user experience. As a field, it has grown out of both UI design and graphic design."

As the definition states, Instructional design is about the content flow, the way of presentation etc. It is a process for content design, that depends on the analysis of performance goals, learners/target audience, training requirements, technological limitations etc. Based on these information, the instructional designer then creates a script or storyboard which dictates how the textual inputs, images, videos, and audio elements will be presented to the audience.

Instructional design determines all the nitty gritty like- usage of game elements, simulation or interactives, the length, the purpose (performance support or general training). This also includes in a broad level the content's visual aspects which otherwise comes under the broader umbrella of visual design (does that make it a subset of Instructional design then?).

Visual design however is handled by s different set of specialists called the graphic designers who actually give life to eLearning. Imagine eLearning for K12 in monotone, boring huh! That's eLearning without visual design. Picking the right color palette and the typeface(that meets accessibility requisites), the layout and navigation, the size, shapes and placement of buttons and other interactive elements etc. comes under visual design. Going overboard with elements, colors etc. can lead to clutter and distraction which weakens the purpose of eLearning, which is why creating a balance is important.

What really works, is a fusion of Instructional design and visual design where each compliments the other. Over the years that we have worked as eLearning providers we have observed that the interactions between instructional designers and graphic designers during the ideation process or after the storyboard creation often helps in bringing out creative solutions. As Jeffrey Zeldman says, "Content precedes design. Design in the absence of content is not design, it's decoration." On the same note in the words of Frank Chimero, "People ignore design that ignores people."

Instructional design may be considered slightly more important, but cannot be completely successful without visual design. So, in conclusion we cannot say that one outdoes the other.

Do you think otherwise? Do share your thoughts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe With Us

Recent Posts
June 4, 2021
Microlearning for Banking and Finance

During the last few years, the top 5 sectors with highest number of employment have been banks, IT, mining, healthcare and textiles. According to Statista, “in 2017, the total number of people employed in financial services sector in the UK amounted to over 1.13 million.” There’s nothing wrong in stating that banking and finance sectors […]

Read More
May 5, 2021
The Importance of Training Evaluation

What is the Importance of Training Evaluation? Why Evaluate Training? Read more to find out why it is important to evaluate every training.

Read More
July 2, 2020
Why Microlearning And Mobile Learning Is an Essential Combination For L&D

In a modern world driven by app-based technologies and workplace applications, mobile is an essential device. A Deloitte report states that “consumers today check their

Read More
Recent Case Studies
December 19, 2020
Only Assessment Skill Assessment App

Knowzies Team developed a solution that consisted of a responsive web application with admin and user functionality. The admin can create assessments and assign those to users based on time and date. There are 6 different types of questions that can be created or bulk uploaded by the admin. This is a highly scalable architecture and is built to handle the load of as much as more than 5000 concurrent users. It had 4 types of users viz super admin, evaluator, and user.

Read More
December 17, 2020
On the SAAS Software Review Platform

Knowzies team offered a solution that consisted of a responsive web application that is available in 4 different languages- English, Spanish, Italian, and French. The main portal offered an excellent search facility to search the required product based on category, feature, pricing, country, etc. It also showed the latest trends in the industry and top 3 products based on the user’s reviews. It had 5 different types of modules like Main Page, Categories (further split into subcategories), market analysis and trends, and some useful resources.

Read More
December 14, 2020
Compliance Training App

Knowzies team created a solution that consisted of a responsive web application with multi-portal functionality. The main portal was integrated with the client’s website. An iOS, as well as an Android mobile app, is also part of the solution. It had 4 types of users viz super admin, master admin, sub-admin, and learner. Knowzies team adopted SCRUM methodology for managing this solution which was built across 8 sprints.

Read More
Knowzies Technology Solutions 
#5, Third Floor Trident Apartment,
Bavdhan, Pune, India

© 2021
 All Rights Reserved
Privacy PolicySitemap
envelopecrossarrow-up linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram